All’s Fair on Disney+ review: Kim Kardashian’s stilted new legal drama is a proper atrocity

All’s Fair on Disney+ Review

Ryan Murphy, known in Hollywood for his questionable taste, has delivered one of the worst series Disney+ has ever offered its audience.

Kim Kardashian’s Unconventional Path

Kim Kardashian, often recognized as the original influencer, has always avoided the obvious route. In 2014, right after her wedding to Kanye West at the Forte di Belvedere in Florence, the couple flew directly to Cork Airport for their honeymoon. Their plans included a stay in Castlemartyr and a visit to Portlaoise, where they attended a 3 p.m. screening of X-Men: Days of Future Past at the local Storm Cinema. Her journey took her off the beaten path, landing in the Midlands on an ordinary weekday in May.

Now divorced from Kanye, Kardashian continues to follow her own rules without concern for public opinion.

A Star-Studded Cast in a Flawed Drama

Despite the show’s many failings, Kardashian's fame has drawn a remarkable cast capable of claiming their own spot on the Hollywood Walk of Fame. This includes the accomplished Naomi Watts, who appears as bewildered as she did when playing a character infatuated with a gorilla in Peter Jackson’s King Kong. Glenn Close also stars, clearly perplexed by the series.

"All’s Fair is a proper atrocity exhibition and one of the worst things Disney+ has ever foisted upon its subscribers."

For those who have endured She-Hulk, this low bar makes the failure of All’s Fair even more glaring.

Author’s Summary

The series “All’s Fair” showcases Kim Kardashian’s unique approach but fails dramatically, resulting in one of Disney+’s most disappointing releases despite its star-packed cast.

more

The Irish Times The Irish Times — 2025-11-05